Reviews from Our Happy Customers


"Everything was wonderful! As always, very accommodating to special requests. Don't want Alfredo sauce? They'll make it with marinara. Thanks for the great experience."

Pasta Perfection!

"For THE best pasta in the Madison area, you have to go to Angelo's! The marinara is so fresh tasting and delicious that you want to just eat it with a spoon! Try the cajun pasta- fettuccine, large shrimp, andouille in a spiced cream sauce. Heaven! Service is excellent! Can't wait to go back."

Wonderful hosts, great food!

"My husband and I live a half hour away in another city, but when we need to get away and relax, we choose Angelos McFarland. Pat and his wife are always friendly and immediately acknowledge us, and we have great beer/drinks while we wait to be seated. Food is always great, service the same. We have always had a really enjoyable evening!"

Some of the best pizza in wisconsin

"Have eaten here many times. NEVER a bad experience. I would recommend this restaurant to everyone. Pizza is served on a dimpled pan to prevent the crust from becoming soggy. Friday fish fry has great choices."

Wonderful relaxing dinner

"I started with the Hendrick's Gin and Tonic with cucumber. So refreshing! This drink has changed forever the way I drink gin & tonic. The cheesy bacon potato soup was extremely flavorful. The salmon with key lime sauce special served on jasmine rice was delicious and served with perfectly cooked broccoli, cauliflower and carrots. A slice of peanut butter pie finished off the dinner nicely. Service was great, atmosphere wonderful. I will definitely be back soon."

New Bartender, Same Great Result!

"When someone just does it right over and over, it is worth mentioning over and over. Shared a 1/2 price bottle of wine with my wife and had a great dinner snuggled up to the cozy bar. Make the short drive to McFarland and I promise you will be glad you did. Appetizer was perfect. Really nice to use the words "Ditto" when getting great service. Thanks for another great visit."

Charming Italian

"This is an absolutely great neighborhood Italian restaurant. Nice people great drinks. Nice selection of homemade Pasta and Pizza. Friday fish fry. Stop by early, because this place gets crowded."

Great place for family dinner

"We moved here in August and we've quickly realized that Angelo's is one of the great places in the McFarland/Monona area for family dinners. The service is always excellent, the food is always very good and the atmosphere is homey! The staff does a great job of making you feel welcome and they always have delicious specials to choose from. Definitely stop by if you're in the area or if you live close, make it a regular spot to enjoy."

See our Reviews on Trip Advisor